ITR-1 or ITR-2: where does the boundary fall?
Most wrong-form returns come from a few grey areas. This table shows where ITR-1 ends and ITR-2 starts.
| Point | ITR-1 | ITR-2 |
|---|
| Who | Resident and ordinarily resident individual | Any individual or HUF, including NRI and RNOR |
| Total income | Up to ₹50 lakh | No limit |
| House property | Up to two | Any number |
| Capital gains | Only LTCG u/s 112A up to ₹1.25 lakh | All capital gains and losses |
| Foreign assets or income | Not allowed | Allowed, with Schedule FA |
| Director or unlisted shares | Not allowed | Allowed |
| Business income | Not allowed | Not allowed (use ITR-3 or ITR-4) |
Each grey area has a clear rule.
1. Equity gains up to ₹1.25 lakh
You can now report LTCG u/s 112A in ITR-1, but only if the gain does not exceed ₹1.25 lakh. Gains up to this amount are exempt, so no tax arises. The moment you have even ₹1 of short-term gain, the form changes. A short-term gain on a mutual fund switch or an SIP redemption within 12 months counts.
Example: You redeemed equity funds and made a long-term gain of ₹90,000. You had no other sale. ITR-1 works, and the gain is fully exempt. If the same year also had a short-term gain of ₹2,000 on one sale, ITR-2 applies.
Check whether your gains are long or short term with the capital gains calculator before you pick the form.
2. Up to two house properties
ITR-1 now accepts up to two house properties. Each can be self-occupied with home loan interest, or let out with rent. The law lets you treat two houses as self-occupied, so their annual value is nil; a third house is treated as deemed let out. A third house, or a house loss you want to carry forward, means ITR-2. A house jointly owned counts for each co-owner, so two flats owned jointly with a spouse are two properties for each of you, which ITR-1 still allows.
The loss from a self-occupied house (home loan interest up to ₹2 lakh in total for self-occupied houses, old regime) can be set off in ITR-1 in the same year. If the loss is more than what can be set off and you want to carry it forward, ITR-1 does not allow that, and ITR-2 is needed.
3. Agricultural income
Farm income up to ₹5,000 sits inside ITR-1. Above ₹5,000, it still remains exempt but must be reported in ITR-2, where it is added to your income only to work out the tax rate on the rest. Rent from agricultural land and sale of crops both count as agricultural income.
Other edge cases
- Clubbed income: interest on an FD in your spouse's name, bought from your money, is added to your income. It can go in ITR-1 if it is under the heads allowed.
- Dividend from foreign shares or RSUs: this is foreign income, so ITR-1 is out.
- Pension from abroad: also foreign income, so ITR-2.